The visible whip of the EU

Alexander Beunder (KSU)
Is Europe itself the ‘invisible hand’ that’s forcing us into an era of austerity which dismantles the welfare state? If we are to believe the words of the British journalist Claud Cockburn – “Never believe anything until it’s officially denied” – then we should conclude that it is.

Van Rompuy to Greece: "Dont blame Europe" (Photo: Council of the European Union)

[Nederlandse versie] vertaald door De zichtbare zweep van de EU

European Council President Van Rompuy told deputies in Strasbourg recently, after criticism of Europe’s austerity-focused response to the bloc’s economic crisis: “Some people fear this work is about dismantling the welfare states and social protection. Not at all … It is to save these fundamental aspects of the European model.” Not only EU-leaders are denying it officially. Dutch politicians are denying it as well if you listen closely. Last February the Dutch Minister of Finance Jan Kees de Jager officialy denied that Europe intends to dictate member states on pension reforms.

If it is not the case that Europe is dismantling welfare states, why is it being denied over and over again? The most obvious explanation is that many, like the Dutch labour union FNV, are countering the official denials by saying that Europe plans to dictate reforms in member states which should be left to national governments and social partners – on issues like pensions, wages and labour relations. The European Trade Union Confederation explained:

Economic governance, as currently proposed by the Commission, is about nothing else than cuts, cuts, cuts: Cutting wages, cutting jobs, cutting protection against easy firing, cutting social benefits, cutting public services. Workers are being presented with all of the huge costs of the crisis.

And the main instrument for this could be a new European pact that is being designed currently. Before the EU negotiations about this new pact started, we were already warned about it by the Corporate Europe Observatory (CEO). They analyzed the proposals in their January report called “Corporate EUtopia – how new economic governance measures challenge democracy“:

A European version of “shock doctrine” is about to be applied in the European Union. In the wake of the euro-crisis, new EU powers to intervene in labour markets and in member states” budgets, including social spending, will effectively impose a neoliberal straitjacket on national economies. Therefore, it is a crucial moment for proponents of a social and democratic Europe to prevent the Union from further degrading into an unaccountable corporate EUtopia.

The pact under discussion would, according to the CEO, pave the way for more EU-control over it’s member states’ fiscal policies. A simple scoreboard does the trick; the EU would be able to sanction member states when they score too low on some economic criteria set up by European technocrats. When a member state is – according to this scoreboard – suffering from excessive imbalances (for instance too generous wages or social benefits) this just might indicate that a country is in risk of running a budget deficit in the future. The EU-Commission might subsequently demand changes in it’s national policy on wages, labour markets or any macroeconomic issue. If these demands are not met, member states could be sanctioned financially, even before a budget deficit actually arises.

We might be facing an era in which the EU takes increasing control of national fiscal policy as part of a “silent revolution” (Barroso’s words) which would bring the EU closer to being a fiscal union. It seems a logical step after agreeing on being a monetary union, a customs union and many other unions, as well as one european education space by the way. Yes, European cooperation seems good, after centuries of European wars. But then the question becomes what kind of politics will rule it. And currently, it seems democratic accountability and public influence are insignificant at the European level, and big business lobby groups set the agenda, if we are to believe the Corporate Europe Observatory (CEO).

But this was probably to be expected. Some day the European Commission would stand up and say to the Eurozone members; “You’re not living up the stability pact, that you yourselves signed! This is threatening the euro. If you’d grant us more power, we’ll fix the problem.”

The stability pact? It’s not much more than the agreement of the participants to keep their yearly budget deficit beneath 3% of GDP. This might have seemed like a harmless, politically neutral clause at the beginning, but it’s now becoming a major issue in the political arena, as was predicted more than a decade ago. Already in 1997 a group of 70 Dutch economists predicted that the harsh stability-pact of the Eurozone would – in times of economic crisis – lead to severe cuts in social spending of which the poor would suffer the most. Social unrest would be the result. Moreover, it would endanger national economies as investments are needed to grow yourself out of a crisis, not austerity.

The question arises what’s left of national fiscal autonomy in a European Monetary Union. If we’re protesting austerity at the doors of our national parliaments, is there still a chance that they will concede to our demands? Less so, it appears. The significance of the European Monetary Union was explained in 2002 by professor of political sciences Werner Bonefeld as follows:

The importance of EMU […] is that national states, on their own initiative, will no longer be able to accommodate class conflict through credit expansion or currency devaluation. EMU, then, inscribes the neo-liberal policy of market freedom… through the creation of supranational institutional devices that check expansionary responses to labour conflict.

As many states now indeed don’t seem to be able to keep their budget deficits below the 3%, especially in these expensive times of economic crises and bailouts to the financial sector, countries are beginning to feel the whip of the EU and the stability pact. Especially countries like Portugal, Ireland, Greece and Spain that might in the end all depend on loans from the EU to grow themselves out of the crisis (and as they are so often called number-manipulating ‘PIGS’, mainstream media refrains from looking at any other economic reason for their budget deficits – like European market integration, differences in competitiveness, speculative capital and a global financial crisis).

Greece was the first one to feel the visible whip of the EU. It accepted a much needed EU-IMF loan after investors suddenly deserted the Greek bond market in April 2010 (nobody ever really understands why they do so at certain times in certain places). In exchange it had to agree to a number of harsh demands, like reducing wages, dismantling social benefits and privatizing the economy, which would then, EU-technocrats argued, bring it’s budget deficit under the 3 percent again, some day. That day still seems far away, as the Greek economy is still not showing signs of recovery, and unemployment (especially for the young) has increased dramatically. As should be expected, social unrest is frequent.

As for the others; Ireland also accepted a controversial rescue-package and Portugal is likely to be the next to accept a EU-IMF loan, an offer they can’t (easily) refuse. Spain claims it’s still surviving without this kind of ‘help’. And of course, there are continuously fears that more European countries besides ‘PIGS’ are facing similar deficit problems.

Now is the perfect time for the European Commission to test how far they can go. In these uncertain times, EU states are increasingly facing sudden attacks on their fiscal balance sheets as international investors desert their bond markets and raise their interest rates. It seems easy for the Commission to sell to it’s member states any plan that might bring back some confidence to international capital markets.

The crucial question now is; how much sovereignty are member states willing to sacrifice for the stability pact? Our own Minister of Finance Jan Kees de Jager seems to be very happy with the pact that’s being designed. If we would have done this before, problems like that of Greece and Portugal could have been prevented, de Jager said.

However, the battle is still being fought. There are signs that these “social partners” are turning their anger increasingly towards Europe, besides or instead of at their own national governments. The EUobserver reported that “on 16 March in Bucharest some 50,000 workers hit the streets, according to the European Trades Union Congress and on 9 April in Budapest, Hungary’s six trade unions are to descend upon a meeting of EU finance ministers.” On March 24th around 20,000 workers from trade unions protested at a EU-summit in Brussels against “the imposition of the deepest level of economic integration in the EU’s history – the delivery of ‘economic governance’ in the union that will require wage restraint, hikes in retirement ages, public sector cutbacks and limits on government spending, amongst other stringent measures”.

It is being denied often enough to get suspicious. And as students, workers, the unemployed or any other concerned citizen, we should get suspicious. Seeing the lack of media-attention, these kinds of pacts might just turn out to be too easy to ram through parliaments without any significant discussion, for no politician would suffer reputational damage if nobody’s paying attention (remember how easy the under reported Lisbon Treaty was adopted in the Netherlands, while the almost identical widely reported European Constitution was rejected).

To conclude. ‘Civil society’ should get suspicious, have a broad discussion about the future of Europe and force politicians to vote against the dismantling of the welfare state. Or we might wake up one day in a European state, without welfare.



1.309 thoughts on “The visible whip of the EU

  1. Pingback: The visible whip of the EU « Kritische Studenten Utrecht

  2. Great article. “nobody ever really understands why [investors suddenly desert] at certain times in certain places”

    The economist Robin Hahnel put it eloquently:

    There are two rules of behavior in any credit system:

    Rule #1 is the rule all participants want all other participants to follow: DON’T PANIC!

    Rule #2 is the rule each participant must be careful to follow herself: PANIC FIRST!

  3. Also interesting: an article (in Dutch) on mejudice which claims Greek and Irish taxpayers are paying German banks, not the other way around!

    “De Mythe van Merkel ontkracht: Europa betaalt voor Duitse banken […] betalen de Griekse en Ierse belastingbetaler dus om te voorkomen dat Duitse banken grote verliezen lijden. Via het eurofonds staat de Nederlandse belastingbetaler garant. Een redenering die haaks staat op die de Duitse pers ons voorschotelt. Maar de Duitsers houden de laatste mythe nog graag in stand.”

  4. Pingback: Do 15 sept. – KSU/Basta! Debate: Europe in chaos, from square to parliament « Kritische Studenten Utrecht

  5. De même que JBGO, je respecte ton avis, mais as-tu quand même essayé W8 ? Objectivement, les améliorations en terme de performances, de rapidité et de fluidité sont énormes par rapport à Seven. Et certes, l’OS manque d’uniformité et le style Metro ne plait pas forcément, mais on peut très bien se passer de toute la dimension Metro et n’utiliser que le bureau (ce que je fais personnellement).

  6. Fantastic packing tips – I always love your holiday wardrobes (and your holidays – proper free spirit travel – love Glastonbury street). We are spending two weeks in France, so I think I'll need to organise a few warm layers too. But we'll be in Freda, so carrying it all will be a little easier

  7. Agree! I am a big fan of Chef Andre after his arrival, so proud having same name as him… Top quality produces with his amazing artistic combination blends of flavor and textures…I highly recommend everyone to go for dinner! enjoy the Extravaganza 7 courses Degustation menu~Andre Tan

  8. Celtic1, please understand this has nothing to with race or tribe, this has to do with society in general, the Lady made a decision which is even okay with her, but condition made her did it, do you know her level of education, she may be poor but she can put that baby for adoption and she can do family planning to prevent pregnancy, she may not know or be aware of all these opportunities. My Dear this kind of thing even happen in developed world, let us all pray for our country and each one of us. Condemn“ not.

  9. “Clot,Oh, I agree. Although I’m not sure what really drives the mentality.Could be a bit of the ol’ “price of everything, vale of nothing”.Or maybe just some kind of deep rooted scepticism or fear of being cheated.I really hope it isn’t some kind of vindicative schadenfreud where the buyer really doesn’t care about price or property, as long as they are sure the seller is financially, mentally, and socially ruined.”Fear of loss, fear of committment.

  10. 1. What steps can you take to reduce the amount of duplicate content on a website?2. What do you think is more important offsite or onsite optimisation? Why?3. How would you find out which keywords we should be optimising the website for?Im so stressed and struggling, would really appreciate someones help on these questions. Thank you xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

  11. early September – but it’s hard to say.Hi Alan-True, there are some differences there. Though, I would argue that we shouldn’t see anything appreciable between the units..well, hopefully anyway. Hi Andy-At this point, it appears the Fenix Bluetooth connect is primary used for sharing routes/waypoints/tracks with phones, but beyond that it’s a bit of a mystery.Thanks all!

  12. You brought up the specter of Jack Thompson! No cookie!If we outlaw guns, only criminals will own guns. Related: did no one learn about the Prohibition in school? I’m as upset about this as everyone else, but even I can see that the last time we tried a ban, it didn’t work, and in fact it made the problem worse.

  13. Nu Facebook als schrikreactie het delen van contacten met Google+ gaat bemoeilijken, zal dat wel eens een extra argument kunnen zijn om Google+ te gaan proberen. Social media gebruikers houden in de regel niet van beperkingen. 3 x is scheepsrecht na Wave en Buzz? Zeker als overstappen naar Google+ gepaard gaat met uitstappen bij Facebook zou je nog wel eens gelijk kunnen krijgen…

  14. Peas and Thank You has become a favorite site. I think you suggested it to me last week I’m not in a big rush for the label but I’m goal oriented and it’s just habit to have a target date. Off to check out Choosing Raw.jillconyers recently posted..

  15. Det kan jeg sagtens følge dig i 🙂 Det mÃ¥ være ret sjovt at se ens egne traditioner blive fortolket og tilpasset pÃ¥ denne mÃ¥de. Da vi boede i Sverige for nogle Ã¥r siden, blev vi inviteret til smørgÃ¥rdstÃ¥rta hos vores søde svenske naboer, den ret synes vi var helt anderledes end vi var vant til fra Danmark 🙂 Jeg elsker sÃ¥danne anderledes oplevelser – ogsÃ¥ selv om det mÃ¥ske ikke lige er alle retter man selv ville lave derhjemme

  16. slowly. “I persist in dreaming it, although it has often seemed to me that it could never come true. I dream of a home with a hearth-fire in it, a cat and dog, the footsteps of friends — and YOU!” – Gilbert Blythe speaking to Anne Shirley in the book

  17. Thanks for clarifications. Which reminds me, I forgot to say that I was impressed that you so deftly made such a difficult revelation metaphorical (with the fruit salad).I am in recovery from alcoholism, almost 20 years now (OK 18, maybe it’s a jinx to round up), and still dream nightly that I am having just. one. drink. In the daytime I never even pause to consider it, but the dreams remind me that I am an addict, nonetheless.

  18. I do agree with all the ideas you’ve offered in your post. They are really convincing and will definitely work. Still, the posts are too quick for novices. May you please extend them a little from next time? Thanks for the post.

  19. I am always striving for ways to improve the condition of my skin and I usually rely on creams and facials to do the work. When I read this book and used some of the recipes I began to see the correlation between eating well and having beautiful skin. Using these antioxidant recipes has helped my skin look and feel more hydrated. My favorite recipe so far is the pretty poached salmon!!!

  20. Desde AS Nacional queremos dar las gracias a Sevilla 28, a la Delegación de Sevilla, a la comunidad Redentorista y a toda la comunidad parroquial por hacer posible que la sequía de Kenia se transforme en agua, en vida, en esperanza y en justicia. Gracias a todos vosotros por vuestro esfuerzo, vuestra ilusión, vuestra entrega y vuestro corazón solidario. Un besote de corazón a corazón. Justi

  21. does new york count as “outside london”? heh.think you mean working outside a media and cultural capital. no way i could do that. but that’s fear talking.i’m still waiting for an agency from iceland (or bradford) to kick everyone’s ass. it’s bound to happen. location should no longer mean anything. strictly speaking.

  22. Fanny, thank you kindly. I'll make sure to tell Mark to pop back to see these sweet remarks.So, there's an apostophe in your moniker? That wasn't considered by the computer geeks, was it? My sympathies on your plight. I wonder if we should start a misspelled-name support group?

  23. Caterpillar shovels clearly shown in the second video from 5/31/11, in service of the illegal Israeli quarry, protected by the IDF, on Palestinian land. Go BDS and shine a bright light on Caterpillar, Motorola, Northrop Grumman, and their ilk profiting from the systematic dispossession of the Palestinians!

  24. And for those of us–gay and straight–who are people of faith, we understand that homophobia is a sin. And the more we confront it and push it back, the more we win. For too long, we cowered in fear of it, but now, we have seen the light!

  25. Tak for kigget. Ja, det er virkelig en sjov fornemmelse at fÃ¥ kort fra nogen man ikke kender sÃ¥ godt – men efterhÃ¥nden kommer vi jo til at kende hinanden. Og det er hyggeligt med alle de kort pÃ¥ son fødselsdag. Og masser af inspiration man kan kigge pÃ¥ med fingrene. God torsdag.

  26. I’m glad you agree with me because I value your opinion a lot. It is a rather silly argument when I hear “the characters just took over!” from a writer, particularly a professional who should know better.

  27. hola,una pregunta y peco de ignorante veo la foto de los famosos vasos de yogur,supongo son de europa aqui en mexico no se manejan esos vasos,podrian decirme de cuanto es la medida??? mil gracias ^^-

  28. It’s appropriate time to make some plans for the future and it is time to be happy. I have read this post and if I could I wish to suggest you few interesting things or tips. Perhaps you could write next articles referring to this article. I wish to read even more things about it!

  29. 1. 好彩我只係玩online game,唔係買迷你債券。:P2. 我覺得有「性格」,係因為發現某些顏色(如紅)特別喜歡「搏」(例如2打2, 3打3之類),有些(如綠)卻較保守,喜歡趨避只打弱者(除非四圍冇更弱既對手)。3. 我覺得最不公道的反而是戰果all or none。Risk 可以「慘勝」(贏家本來有大軍都可以打到剩番一隻兵),但這個卻沒有,贏就是贏盡。攻方的八贏了就是剩下七,守方有七或一都沒關係。

  30. Peppo:”che bello non avere più di questi problemi eh riccardo?ormai mi metto a ridere sentendo parlare di virus, malware e roba del genere.”Ridi ridi che intanto, almeno per il Mac, i virus cominciano ad arrivare… Come ho scritto nel mio blog: più un sistema operativo è diffuso tra la gente e più vengono fuori i buchi.Comunque, volevo chiedere per che versioni di windows è fatto questo virus.Grazie

  31. The core of your writing whilst appearing reasonable at first, did not really settle very well with me after some time. Somewhere throughout the sentences you actually were able to make me a believer unfortunately only for a short while. I however have got a problem with your jumps in assumptions and you would do well to fill in those breaks. In the event that you can accomplish that, I will undoubtedly be fascinated.

  32. யப்பா ஹரிகுமாரா,நீங்க யூ.எஸ்., யூ.கே.ன்னு போயிடுவீங்க, அயோத்தியா மண்டபத்துல பூணூல் விக்கற பஞ்சைப் பார்ப்பான் எங்கே போவான்..?! திராவிட வீர சூரர்களால் வெட்டிவீழ்த்தப்பட்ட பார்ப்பன பாசிசத் தீவிரவாதியாகச் செத்தாலும் சாவானே தவிர போவதற்கு வேற போக்கிடம் இல்லாத அவனைப் போன்ற பஞ்சைகள் தான் பார்ப்பனர்களில் பாதிக்கு மேல் இங்கே…

  33. Zune and iPod: Most people compare the Zune to the Touch, but after seeing how slim and surprisingly small and light it is, I consider it to be a rather unique hybrid that combines qualities of both the Touch and the Nano. It’s very colorful and lovely OLED screen is slightly smaller than the touch screen, but the player itself feels quite a bit smaller and lighter. It weighs about 2/3 as much, and is noticeably smaller in width and height, while being just a hair thicker.

  34. That sort of history can shape a people. That sort of history did. It’s no surprise that Russian culture is marked by a xenophobic siege mentality. I don’t quite blame them for that. Though I believe in personal and/or cultural responsibility. If you create and maintain an unpleasant culture, you are stuck with it. I may not blame them. I’m still glad I don’t have to endure it.

  35. I blog frequently and I seriously thank you for your information. This article has truly peaked my interest. I am going to book mark your blog and keep checking for new details about once a week. I subscribed to your Feed as well.

  36. Thanks for your blog post. I would also love to say that a health insurance agent also works for the benefit of the coordinators of any group insurance policy. The health insurance broker is given a summary of benefits needed by someone or a group coordinator. Exactly what a broker does indeed is find individuals or perhaps coordinators which in turn best fit those demands. Then he reveals his recommendations and if the two of you agree, the particular broker formulates binding agreement between the two parties.

  37. I found many websites offering me to get hundreds of thousands of articles plus ebooks for only 40 or 50 USD!!!Are those websites legitimate? I am looking for content to translate from English to my native language and publish it in my language for myself.Where I can find legitimate and reliable private label content on the Web?Thanks!Waleed

  38. I've had a hard time shopping online and you laid what I should know before getting online. I haven't measured myself, problem 1, and have not done that much research, problem 2. So thank you for the well thought out post!

  39. Thank you very much. As an indie game developer, programming and 3D modeling are my most familiar skill sets. The basics on how to use photoshop for concept art would be a highly valuable asset to me, as I’m sure it would be to others. Your comprehensive tutorials are excellent. All it would require is a short pause to explain what menu/button/selections you are using to switch between colors and shades.

  40. Het Cruijff-stukje had juist langer moeten zijn en wat beter uitgewerkt, als een rode draad. Zodra Manders begint valt de spot dood en dat is jammer. De kunst is om de spot te bekijken vanuit het oogpunt van iemand die nog niet weet wat hij/zij gaat stemmen. Zou zo iemand nu stemmen op de LP? Ik acht die kans klein.

  41. What the Extreme Q also has though is a remote control,this makes it far more versatile for vaporizing for various uses such as using your herbal for aromatherapy.The Plenty can be described as a robust and powerful hand-held unit. Very few companies offer return shipping so the main thing to focus on is the warranty offered with each unit and it's features.

  42. OK, I've always been worried about duplicate content – particularly with regards to articles I've written. So many 'SEO experts' say you need to spin every article to make it appear unique. I write articles for my blogs (example and then submit the same articles to sites like Ideamarketers and Articlebase in the hope of getting recognition, syndication and, ultimately, backlinks. Perhaps now I can worry a little less about being penalised for having identical content, although I still feel a little uneasy!

  43. Katie, I feel as though I know you, as Alice speaks of you often and if I recall correctly I think I’ve heard Lea refer to you. You are also gifted at capturing the essence of events in words as well as photos. Thank you for sharing both. Their story is timely.

  44. By Carolina Santiago-Sota 31 de mayo de 2008 – 1:25 am¡Hola! Hace unos días, “naufragando” en la www pude encontrar esta conferencia. Aunque comunicóloga de carrera estoy buscando desarrollarme en educación y/formación utilizando las TIC y he encontrado en su sitio personal mucha información muy valiosa para este “viaje” que he decidido emprender. Muchísimas gracias por compartir. Esperando regresar pronto por aquí, reciba un saludo desde México.Carolina SS.

  45. salamsolmaz jan ki gofteh keh emtiazeh pezeshki 20 hesab miisheh?man gabl az ersaleh madarek katban az dameshgh porsidam va beh man katban pasokh dadan keh Ph.D hesab misheh yani 25 emtiaz.agar manba movasaghi dari mamnoon misham?

  46. Youtube Staff,Please reinstate:XenuTV1 and brettkeaneIf you are allowing a multiple suspended person to continue to make accounts on Youtube like theTruthtony48075, then be fair and bring back the two I have mentioned.

  47. #$%#$%&s?I was planning on leaving the condos out through mid summer, expecting that I might get some leaf-cutter bees move in to some of the empty bamboo tubes.I’m feeling guilty that I’m dooming my bee babies to the flies.Disheartened in Brooklyn,Jess

  48. Fortunately, once we have been persuaded to change our mind about something, we are really good at retrofitting our memories to make it look–even to ourselves–that we have always believed what we currently believe, or, at least, that what we currently believe is the logical outcome of what we have always believed. Precisely because we value being consistent, we are more than willing to alter our own memories to convince us that we are.

  49. Intanto parliamone, era quanto dicevo a proposito della carnevalata di Alberobello.I nostri consiglieri di maggioranza ascoltino i cittadini, le lamentele, i bisogni, fate incontri periodici.Riguardo le bracerie resto dell’opinione di tolleranza zero. Almeno una volta all’anno si vada a controllare il rispetto della normativa e il pagamento dei tributi comunali (TOSAP, ICI, TARSU, ecc.). Che belle sigle. Le tasse devono pagarle tutti, altrimenti come fa il Comune a erogare i servizi? chi non le paga, danneggia chi le paga.Mannaggia mi viene in mente un’altra battuta di Totò: “E io pago”.

  50. As many will agree, passive aggression is about the most frustrating behavior to deal with. The worst thing about these people is that they continue to slowly push the envelope trying to test how far he/she can go before getting a really negative reaction. What is the best way to deal with such a person? All advice appreciated.(P.S. I am well aware that avoiding the people all together is the best option. However it is not an option in my particular case. So thanks anyways to those who make this suggestion)Thanks again for all advice.

  51. Quite an interesting take on the Barton issue. However, could you provide some of which you consider to be the “wealth of incontrovertible evidence” for evolution? I have yet to see anything incontrovertible for either side.

  52. “Você está abandonando a razão e ficando só com a emoção. Isso não dá em boa coisa. A pessoa acaba se perdendo nas próprias falas.”Não, não estou me perdendo, só estou fazendo uma compraraçã, em que se ele julga a todos nós cristãos por aquilo que alguns cristãos fizeram de errado no passado, vou utilizar deste mesmo critério para comparar o que os pagãos fizeram aos primeiros cristãos e julgá-los pelo mesmo critério.